Mental Health in Criminal Defense: Evolving Strategies and Their Impact on the Justice System

Man in black zip up jacket

The Historical Relationship Between Mental Health and Criminal Law

Mental health has been intertwined with criminal law for centuries. However, the perspective and understanding of mental illnesses have significantly evolved.

From viewing mental illness as a sign of moral failure or weakness, society has progressed to a more compassionate and scientific understanding of these conditions.

The legal system, mirroring societal changes, has slowly started to consider mental health in its proceedings.

Today, we see that mental health issues can play a crucial role in shaping defense strategies and determining the course of a criminal case.

The Recent Surge in Mental Health Awareness: A National Perspective

Across the United States, mental health has taken center stage. Recognizing that mental health is as important as physical health, society is gradually removing the stigma attached to mental illnesses.


With this, we see a considerable shift in various fields, including education, healthcare, workplace environments, and, notably, the criminal justice system.

Legal professionals and law enforcement agencies are becoming more attuned to mental health issues, realizing the profound impact they can have on an individual's actions and decisions.

Current North Carolina Laws on Mental Health as a Defense

North Carolina, like many other states, recognizes the importance of mental health in criminal proceedings.

State laws provide for the defense of insanity and diminished capacity, which hinge on the defendant's mental state at the time of the offense.

The insanity defense can absolve a defendant from liability if it's proven that they couldn't understand the nature or wrongfulness of their actions due to a mental disease or defect.

On the other hand, diminished capacity, while not an outright defense, can aid in reducing the severity of charges or penalties by proving the defendant's impaired mental state. Under the NC Criminal Laws, diminished capacity does not serve as a defense to what are deemed “general intent crimes.”

One would be remiss in noting that both the insanity defense and diminished capacity can be problematic at best for legal counsel. Indeed, criminal cases involving the effective deployment of the insanity defense remain relatively rare in North Carolina.

The Impact of Mental Health Disorders on Criminal Behavior

Mental health disorders can significantly influence a person's thoughts, feelings, and behavior.

Certain disorders, like schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, can affect a person's perception of reality, potentially leading to unlawful behavior. That said, it's crucial to remember that not all individuals with mental health conditions engage in criminal acts.

The relationship between mental health and criminal behavior is complex, influenced by a range of factors, including environmental circumstances, individual resilience, and the availability of supportive resources.

The Role of Expert Witnesses in Mental Health Defenses

In cases where mental health is a central issue, expert witnesses can play a pivotal role in the disposition of the matter.

Psychiatrists, psychologists, or other mental health professionals often provide essential testimony regarding the defendant's mental state.

Their expert opinions, derived from comprehensive assessments and their professional experience, can influence the court's (and jury’s) understanding of the defendant's actions and their culpability.

The Implications for Sentencing and Rehabilitation

When mental health is factored into a criminal case, it can significantly affect the sentencing process.

In North Carolina, judges have some discretion to consider a defendant's mental health in determining the appropriate sentence.

For instance, if the court is convinced that the defendant's actions were substantially influenced by a mental disorder, they might choose to mandate treatment as a part of the sentence.

This approach underscores a shift from a purely punitive model towards one that aims at rehabilitation and societal reintegration.

Potential Pitfalls and Ethical Considerations

While the recognition of mental health in criminal law represents progress, it's not without challenges.

There's the potential for misuse of mental health defenses, with some fearing they could be inferred as a “get out of jail free” card.

To prevent such misuse, courts generally implement rather stringent requirements for proving affirmative defenses.

Moreover, it raises ethical questions about responsibility, free will, and justice, reflecting the ongoing debate about the nature of mental illnesses and their impact on an individual's actions.

How Criminal Defense Attorneys Can Advocate for Clients with Mental Health Issues

In dealing with clients who have mental health conditions, defense attorneys must strive for a holistic understanding of their client's individual issues and prior psychiatric histories.

This includes gaining a thorough understanding of their client's mental health conditions, procuring appropriate expert evaluations, and making sure their client's rights are protected throughout the legal proceedings.

That can prove difficult in some instances, as some individuals may be unable to assist in their own defense, cooperate with counsel in a meaningful manner, and can, in fact, prove to be an obstruction to the effective presentation of an affirmative defense.

An attorney's role isn't merely to represent the client in court but also to help ensure that the accused’s mental health needs are adequately addressed, when possible, and considered at the important stages of the case and legal process.

Looking Toward the Future: Policy Changes and Implications

As mental health awareness continues to grow, legal policies and practices will undoubtedly adapt.

Potential policy changes could include more robust protections for defendants with mental illnesses, greater use of therapeutic justice models, and increased availability of mental health resources within the justice system.

These changes could revolutionize how criminal law interacts with mental health, leading to a more empathetic and effective justice system.


Why do I need an Attorney for My Case?

Having legal representation helps ensure that your rights are protected. An attorney can guide you through the complexities of the legal process, develop a defense strategy, and represent your best interests in court. This is particularly important when dealing with mental health issues, as these can significantly influence your case.

When is the best time to consult a lawyer?

The best time to consult a lawyer is as soon as you're aware of potential criminal charges against you. Early consultation allows the attorney to take immediate steps to protect your rights and start gathering information for your defense.

When is the best time to hire a lawyer?

The ideal time to hire a lawyer is as soon as you become aware that you're under investigation or immediately following an arrest. Prompt legal representation can help prevent inadvertent self-incrimination and help ensure your rights are upheld from the outset.

What do I need to know about criminal charges in North Carolina?

North Carolina's criminal law system is intricate and can be daunting to navigate. The consequences of criminal charges can vary widely, from fines and community service to imprisonment. Regardless of the nature of the charges, having an attorney guide you through the process can be a crucial factor in dealing with the situation effectively.

Helpful Information about Criminal Charges in North Carolina

Get A Confidential Consultation

Get Started Today

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.